We’ve covered decision-making in agency project management before – in our first piece on the topic, two agency leaders shared how they navigate project pivots and high-stakes calls. The responses were pointed enough that we decided to keep asking. This time, we brought the same questions to two very different teams: Brut Marketing, a boutique strategy and marketing agency operating between Bali and LA, and Superbase, an independent brand design and strategy firm based in Boise, Idaho.
Same questions. Different contexts. Genuinely different answers.
When Rebuilding Is The Smarter Move
Not every project can be salvaged by iteration. Sometimes the most efficient path forward is back to zero – and recognizing that early is its own skill.
Have you ever had to rebuild or redo a project from scratch? What led to that situation?
Dian Andrusary, Partner at Brut Marketing:
Yes – more than once. Usually, it happens when a project moves into design or promotion too quickly, before the foundation is really defined. A brand may already have a logo, a website, or some market activity, but the positioning is still blurry, the audience is too broad, or the product story is not sharp enough. In those cases, trying to “fix” things layer by layer often wastes more time than starting over with strategy and building properly from there.
Changing Course Mid-Project – and Knowing When It’s Necessary
Stopping a project mid-process is a harder call than it sounds. The work is already underway, time and money are in, and changing direction means admitting the original path wasn’t right.
Have you ever stopped a project mid-process because you believed the direction was wrong?
Dian: Yes – especially in product or service launches where the first goal is not to scale immediately, but to test viability. In those cases, we often go to market with an MVP version, a focused offer, and a set of working hypotheses around audience, positioning, and value proposition. Sometimes the market response shows that the initial assumption is simply not strong enough. When that happens, we would rather pause, step back, and rethink the core proposition than keep pushing a direction that is not being validated. For us, that is not failure – it is part of a strategic process.
Kelly Williams, Founder and Creative Director of Superbase:
Mid-project pivots aren’t uncommon, and can happen in varying degrees and for various reasons. For example, we’ve had projects that required drastic changes in the direction due to client name changes, trademark issues, or leadership changes on the client side. Of course, those are all external factors. As far as changing directions during a project because of some sort of evolution with the creative internally – yes, this has happened too. If, throughout the course of the project, we notice that something isn’t working or we receive new information that impacts the direction, we must adapt to this. Although it’s very rare, this can certainly happen, and we’re not too stubborn to admit if something isn’t working. We want to be proud of the work. So, if it becomes clear that we would not be proud of the work, we pause, re-evaluate, and adjust.
The Decisions That Shape Everything Else
Every project involves dozens of small calls, but a few carry disproportionate consequences – the ones that set the direction everything else follows.
What type of decision in your work carries the most responsibility or risk?
Dian: The most high-stakes decisions are always the early strategic ones: positioning, audience prioritisation, offer logic, and go-to-market direction. A visual mistake can usually be corrected. But a wrong strategic decision affects everything that comes after it – website structure, messaging, content, campaign mechanics, media budget, and ultimately how the market understands the brand. That is why we treat early-stage thinking with the same seriousness as final execution.
Kelly: I believe that our branding work requires the most planning, research, and insight. It can be a risky endeavor to start a new brand or undergo a rebrand. There can be a lot of resources invested into it. So, we try to help our clients understand that it is worthwhile to take the time necessary to do it right. Much of the responsibility is in the form of expectation management, and being able to navigate subjective topics in order to keep the work moving forward.
Owning Mistakes: How Agencies Handle Accountability
Things go wrong in every long-term client relationship. What distinguishes good agencies isn’t a perfect track record – it’s how they respond when something breaks.
How do you handle responsibility when a decision made by your team causes problems for the client?
Dian: First, we take responsibility quickly and directly. No hiding behind the process, no trying to soften the issue. Then we break the situation down very clearly: what happened, what impact it created, what can be fixed immediately, and what needs to change internally so it does not happen again. In our experience, clients can forgive mistakes much faster than they can forgive defensiveness or a vague response.
Kelly: As the founder and director of the studio, the responsibility always ultimately falls on my shoulders. So even if my team or a member of my team makes a call that causes a problem for the client, the client doesn’t view that as a one-on-one issue. It’s something that affects the entire business. I try to always stand by my teams’ decisions and support them, but if there is clearly a bad judgement call, Superbase owns up to it, and we adjust internally. If there is good chemistry with the client, we all understand that we are working together toward a common goal. Problems aren’t usually the result of only one decision. There is almost always a pattern or some underlying issues that can be discovered and resolved in order to avoid an impasse.
The Strangest Brief They’ve Ever Worked Around
Agency project management rarely stays within the lines of the original brief. Occasionally it goes somewhere nobody planned for.
What was the strangest or most unusual requirement you had to design or build around?
Dian: One of the more unusual challenges was working on a tennis platform that had to serve very different needs inside one ecosystem. It was not just about making a nice interface – the product had to combine booking, CRM functionality, web and app experiences, and features for both players and tennis businesses. The real challenge was making something quite complex feel intuitive and coherent for very different users. Projects like that force you to think beyond pages or screens and design around an entire system.
Kelly: This isn’t necessarily a design requirement, but as far as strange moments in my career – one that comes to mind was self-inflicted, actually. Working as the Creative Director for a footwear company at the time, I had this idea for a product photoshoot that would require some snakes slithering around the product. A reptile rental business in Southern California turned out to be the solution. The budget didn’t stretch to the optional snake handler, so I signed a waiver and opted to handle them myself. Snakes aren’t really my thing – but people in Hollywood do this kind of stuff all the time, so how hard could it be? Picking up a bunch of snakes and trying to bring out the supermodel in them was a pretty new experience, to say the least. They crawled all over me, but the project got done with no bites. Honestly, I’m convinced the snakes shared my sense of humor about the whole thing.
Final Thoughts
What stands out across both conversations is that strong agency leadership is rarely about always getting it right the first time. It’s about knowing when to pause, when to rebuild, when to defend a direction, and when to admit it no longer works. Whether it’s a boutique strategy team or an independent design studio, the common thread is a willingness to stay flexible without losing conviction. The best decisions in agency project management often happen long before launch day – in the uncomfortable moments where teams choose clarity over momentum, honesty over ego, and long-term outcomes over short-term convenience.
Explore More Agencies
If you’re an agency, designer, or startup looking to boost your visibility, you can join Norobots and become part of our curated network of trusted businesses. If you’re a brand or client searching for the right partner, our platform helps you discover agencies, designers, and startups you can rely on. Browse the listings and find the right fit for your next project!
