The Client Acquisition Strategies Agencies Swear By (And What They’ve Abandoned)
Client acquisition is one of the most talked-about – and often misunderstood – aspects of running a creative business. While there’s no shortage of advice online, the reality is that the most effective client acquisition strategies tend to be highly personal, shaped by experience, relationships, and lessons learned the hard way.
We’ve gathered insights from three creative agency leaders who share what’s working, what hasn’t, and how they think about attracting the right kind of work.
High-Performing Channels and Where Quality Comes From
Not all acquisition channels are created equal. Some bring volume, others bring alignment – and the difference matters.
What are your top two client acquisition channels right now, and which one brings the highest-quality projects?
Courtney Todd, fractional CMO, creative director and founder of Umlaut Agency:
Referrals and past clients, hands down. Most of the work coming in is through people I’ve already worked with or people they’ve introduced me to. Those projects are almost always the best fit. There’s already trust, they understand the value of strategic work, and we can skip the back-and-forth and get straight into solving real problems. I also often have people who find me through LinkedIn or my website.
Josh Denberg, creative director and founder of Division of Labor:
We are pretty well known within the Series B startup community due to our past projects, so word of mouth continues to be our strongest client acquisition channel. The founder community in San Francisco is quite tight-knit and we really value when happy clients pass our name along. In addition, SEO/GEO – particularly with third-party references – play a major role. Many clients often find us by searching online or asking tools like ChatGPT or Claude for top ad agencies for Series B startups and B2B tech companies. Because of that, we make an effort to stay current, even as things evolve quickly in that space.
Vincent Romeo, creative director and owner of Romeo + Co:
My current acquisition channels include reaching out to my existing contact list, sending email blasts, referrals, and social media. Out of all of these, referrals tend to bring in the highest-quality projects, as they come with a level of trust and familiarity that makes the working relationship much smoother from the start.
What Client Acquisition Strategies Didn’t Work – and Why It Matters
Failure is an underrated teacher in client acquisition. Often, what doesn’t work tells you more about your business than what does.
What have you tried for client acquisition that didn’t work, and what did you learn from it?
Courtney: Cold email never really clicked for me. I know it works for some people, but it’s never felt aligned with how I build relationships or how my clients make decisions. The work I do usually starts with trust and context, and cold outreach just doesn’t create that in a meaningful way
Josh: We tried direct cold calling, and it ended up being a big failure for us. We hired someone dedicated to it and were doing 10 or more intro calls a month with potential clients for almost a year, but it ultimately led to nothing. It was a valuable lesson in understanding that not every traditional outreach method fits every business, and that our efforts are better spent on channels that align more naturally with how our clients prefer to engage.
Vincent: I once tried to reposition my approach by introducing a completely new system, but it failed pretty badly. It was a useful learning experience, though – it showed me that not every change or new strategy will resonate, and that it’s important to test ideas carefully and stay grounded in what already works.
The Clients Worth Saying No To
Client acquisition isn’t just about getting more work – it’s about getting the right work. Knowing what to avoid is just as important as knowing what to pursue.
What type of projects or clients do you actively avoid today?
Courtney: I tend to avoid companies that don’t align with my values, as that usually creates friction over time. I’m also cautious with clients who want pure execution without taking a step back to think strategically, because that often leads to short-term fixes rather than meaningful results. Similarly, teams where everything is reactive and no one truly owns decisions can be challenging to work with. I’ve learned the hard way that even strong work tends to fall apart in those kinds of environments, no matter how good the initial output is.
Josh: Our work in the Series B tech space is our bread and butter, so we rarely turn down projects in that area. That said, we do actively avoid working with clients who aren’t respectful or enjoyable to collaborate with. No matter the industry, we believe it’s important to work with people we genuinely respect – life’s too short to spend time on difficult or negative working relationships.
Vincent: I’ve had strong success in areas like retail packaging and sports branding, and I know where my strengths lie. Right now, I see a lot of opportunity in toys, games, and outdoor products, but accessing the right contacts in that space has been a challenge. Rather than avoiding specific types outright, I’m more focused on finding better entry points into the industries where I know there’s demand.
Time vs. Impact: What Wasn’t Worth It
Some efforts feel productive but don’t actually move the business forward. Recognizing these early can save months – or years – of wasted energy.
What marketing effort took the most time but produced the least real business impact?
Courtney: Probably organic social when it’s treated as the main ROI driver. It’s great for staying visible, building credibility, and keeping your brand top of mind, but on its own, it hasn’t consistently translated into high-quality leads. I’ve found it works much better as a supporting channel that reinforces other efforts, rather than being relied on as the primary growth engine.
Josh: Organized, formal pitches and RFPs are actually the least productive and the biggest waste of time. Tons of work and often even if we “win” the budgets are rarely worth it. That said, we still consider pitches selectively and are open to paid pitch opportunities, which feel much more balanced and worthwhile. At this point, we’ve moved away from unpaid pitches unless the opportunity is truly exceptional and aligns strongly with our goals.
Vincent: Promotional mailings and online advertising have taken a significant amount of time and effort, but haven’t delivered meaningful business results for me. While they can have some visibility benefits, they haven’t translated into the kind of high-quality leads or projects that justify the investment.
When Reputation Matters More Than Budget
Sometimes, the right project isn’t the highest-paying one. Strategic trade-offs can play a role in long-term growth – if approached carefully.
Have you ever taken a project for its reputational value despite a low budget?
Courtney: Yes, but it’s usually because I believe in the person or what they’re building. Some of those projects have turned into long-term relationships or opened doors I wouldn’t have expected. It’s never about exposure for the sake of it. There has to be real potential or alignment behind the decision.
Josh: Of course. We look at reputational value in terms of both the creative potential of the campaign and the growth trajectory of the brand. If a project has a smaller budget but offers strong creative opportunities, or if we see significant upside in the company’s future, we’re open to it. We tend to evaluate startups a bit like investors – considering the product, the team, and the long-term potential – so we’re sometimes willing to accept less in the short term if we believe the long-term payoff could be meaningful.
Vincent: Earlier in my career, I did take on projects primarily for their reputational value, even if the budget was low. At that stage, it made sense as a way to build a portfolio and credibility. More recently, though, I’ve moved away from that approach and focus more on projects that are both creatively and financially worthwhile.
Final Thoughts
If there’s one consistent thread across these perspectives, it’s this: the best client acquisition strategies are built on trust, alignment, and clarity – not just activity.
Referrals outperform cold outreach. Fit matters more than volume. And not every “growth tactic” is worth your time.
Instead of chasing every possible lead, the smarter approach is to double down on relationships, stay visible in the right places, be selective about who you work with, and continuously refine based on what actually leads to great work.
Because at the end of the day, the goal isn’t just more clients – it’s better ones.
Explore More Agencies
If you’re an agency, designer, or startup looking to boost your visibility, you can join Norobots and become part of our curated network of trusted businesses.
If you’re a brand or client searching for the right partner, our platform helps you discover agencies, designers, and startups you can rely on. Browse the listings and find the right fit for your next project!